Want our top 10 essential dessert recipes?

Get our favorite classic recipes in your inbox! It’s 100% free, but we might make you hungry!

Peeps Bunny Pudding Cups

Simple, no bake easter dessert! Peeps bunny pudding cups with oreos, pudding, coconut, a mini carrot and peeps!
Peeps bunny pudding dirt cups with oreos, pudding, coconut, a mini carrot and a peep in a glass dessert bowl
I am a sucker for peeps because they are like tiny marshmallow-y animals that make any treat instantly cuter.

Last year’s recipe for swimming peeps jello cups was a huge hit! And they are so simple to make – blue jello, cool whip, blue food coloring, and chick peeps. We followed suit and decided to do another fun peep treat this year. We’ll probably share a new recipe each easter season because peeps are such an iconic easter treat, and the possibilities seem endless!

We’re calling this recipe peeps bunny pudding cups!

Peeps bunny pudding dirt cups with oreos, pudding, coconut, a mini carrot and a peep in a glass dessert bowl

How to make peeps bunny pudding dirt cups

The ingredients you’ll need include:
-pistachio pudding (plus 2 cups milk listed on back)
-oreos, crushed into crumbs
-shredded coconut
-green food coloring
-baby carrots
-parsley
-peeps bunnies

The amount of each ingredient you’ll need is dependent on how many cups you want to make.

To make about 6 pudding cups (in 5.3oz glasses)..
-1 package of oreos should be plenty
-1 package of pudding will make five to six pudding cups if using wider bowls like I did
-1/2 cup of shredded coconut will be plenty
-a baby carrot per cup will be needed
-a small amount of parsley
-a bunny peep per cup will be needed

I’d estimate that it’d take less than 25 minutes to prep the ingredients – to pulse the oreos in a food processor or blender, make the pudding, dye the coconut, and make toothpick holes in the baby carrots. You could do all of that in advance, even a few days in advance of when you want to serve the cups.

how to assemble peeps bunny pudding dirt cups collage picture

How to assemble peeps bunny pudding dirt cups

In small cups, bowls or glasses (these are the bowls I used) add a few tablespoons of oreo crumbs, a few spoonfuls of pistachio pudding, sprinkle on green coconut, insert a small amount of parsley into the hole in your carrot, put the carrot in the pudding, and top the pudding cup with a bunny peep! You could have quite a few assembled in 10 minutes.

If you don’t think your kids will be a big fan of pistachio pudding, you could use vanilla, white chocolate or cheesecake pudding (or any pudding that is white) plus a small amount of green food coloring to turn the pudding green.

Peeps bunny pudding dirt cups with oreos, pudding, coconut, a mini carrot and a peep in a glass dessert bowlThis would be a fun treat to serve during the spring season to anticipate Easter or you could keep this recipe handy after the eater bunny delivers his goodies!

I’m thinking peeps should develop a whole line of marshmallow animals – would anyone else be excited about dinosaur peeps?!

peeps bunny pudding dirt cups in glass bowl
Peeps Bunny Pudding Cups

Peeps Bunny Pudding Cups

Additional Time: 25 minutes
Total Time: 25 minutes

Simple, no bake easter dessert! Easter Peeps bunny pudding cups are made with oreos, pudding, coconut, a mini carrot and peeps! Easter Bunny Dirt Cups are an easy treat to make with your kids!

Ingredients

  • Pistachio Pudding 3.4oz (plus 2 cups milk listed on back)
  • Oreos, crushed into crumbs
  • Shredded coconut
  • Green food coloring
  • Baby carrots
  • Parsley
  • PEEPS Bunny’s

Instructions

  1. Make the pistachio pudding according to the directions on the back of the box.
  2. Pulse the oreos into crumbs using a food process or or blender.
  3. Place the shredded coconut and green food coloring in a ziploc bag, close and shake well to dye the coconut.
  4. Create small holes in the tops of the baby carrots with a toothpick. This is where you’ll stick a small piece of parsley to make the leafy green top for the carrot.

To assemble the cups

  1. In small cups, bowls or glasses (these are the bowls I used) add a few tablespoons of oreo crumbs, add more or less as preferred.
  2. Add a few spoonfuls of pistachio pudding as desired.
  3. Sprinkle green coconut on top of the pudding.
  4. Insert a small amount of parsley into the hole in your carrot then put the carrot in the pudding.
  5. Top the pudding cup with a bunny peep!

Notes

The amount of each ingredient you’ll need is dependent on how many cups you want to make.

Recommended Products

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn a small commission from qualifying purchases.

Simple, no bake easter dessert! Peeps bunny pudding cups with oreos, pudding, coconut, a mini carrot and peeps!

5 comments

  1. Aren’t these just so cute! Definitely going to be getting some Peeps this Easter now. 

  2. This is way too cute, Beth!! You are so creative =D

  3. Can you think of an alternative to coconut?

  4. Pingback: 20 Fun and Delicious Peeps Treats

Leave a Reply to Thalia @ butter and brioche Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Top