Want our top 10 essential dessert recipes?

Get our favorite classic recipes in your inbox! It’s 100% free, but we might make you hungry!

Banana Split Pudding Pops

Banana Split Pudding Pops | thefirstyearblog.com
Summertime is banana split time.

I remember when I was young, my mom would take us to go get ice cream and we’d all share a banana split.

When my mom and nephew were in town visiting last week, we went to get ice cream, and what did my mom get? A banana split! Just like good old times. It was fun, but unfortunately I didn’t split it with her because I was too consumed with my snickers and reese’s blizzard.. mmm.

Banana Split Pudding Pops | thefirstyearblog.com
The traditional flavors in a banana split consist of vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry ice cream with pineapple, strawberry and chocolate sauces. And of course 1 banana, split down the center, topped with a maraschino cherry.

We created a fun twist to the traditional banana split – and it’s in our favorite form – POPSICLES!

These Banana Split Pudding Pops are going to be your favorite summertime popsicle – I mean just look at those layers of deliciousness!

There is a rich Dulce de leche layer which tastes like a mix of butterscotch and caramel. Then a classic chocolate pudding layer, topped off with banana pudding layer with maraschino cherries mixed in.

Banana Split Pudding Pops | thefirstyearblog.com
I have a time saving tip for you. This recipe calls for Dulce de leche pudding. You could go looking for Dulce de leche pudding in the packaged pudding aisle, but you won’t find it there, even if you scour the aisle for 20 minutes like I did.

I actually found the Dulce de leche pudding by accident. I was grabbing some yogurt, and what do I see? The refrigerated pudding section! I never buy refrigerated pre-made pudding, but if you’re looking for the Dulce de leche pudding that’s where it will be. And it’s delicious.

Banana Split Pudding Pops | thefirstyearblog.com
Don’t forget, you can save our recipes to your Recipe Box and create meal plans by clicking “Save Recipe.”

Banana Split Pudding Pops

Banana Split Pudding Pops

Yield: 10-12 popsicles


  • Banana Pudding, 1 package
  • Chocolate Pudding, 1 package
  • Dulce de leche Pudding, comes in a standard package of 4 pre-made cups
  • Maraschino Cherries, sliced in quarters

The amount of pudding needed will depend on how many popsicles you would like to make. This recipe could easily make 10-12 popsicles if you want to use all the pudding up.


  1. Prepare the banana pudding and chocolate pudding as directed on their packages. Allow them to set for 1 hour.
  2. Quarter the maraschino cherries. Using a paper towel, squeeze the excess juice from the cherries.
  3. Mix the cherries into the banana pudding.
  4. Using a popsicle mold, begin to layer the pudding.
  5. I found it easiest to transfer each pudding to a ziploc bag with the corner cut off and pipe the pudding into the mold.
  6. Pipe the banana pudding with cherries into the mold, tap the mold against the counter to release any air bubbles. Repeat the process of piping the pudding into the mold and releasing the air bubbles with the chocolate and Dulce de leche pudding.
  7. Insert the sticks into the popsicle mold, and freeze over night.
  8. Once set, place the popsicle mold in several inches of room temperature water to help loosen the pudding pops. The mold only needs to be in the water for several seconds. You can always re-dip if necessary.
  9. Once the pudding pops have been removed, wrap the extras in plastic wrap and store in the freezer for later use.

Banana Split Pudding Pops | thefirstyearblog.com
If you are looking to buy a popsicle mold that uses wooden popsicle sticks, the one I use and suggest is the Norpro Ice Pop Maker.


  1. These are adorable. I’m celebrating Banana Split week on the blog starting tomorrow, wish I had thought to make these as one of the recipes!!! YUM

  2. My daughter will flip over these. She loves to make popsicles.

  3. These are so ridiculously great, Beth!!! Perfect for summer!

  4. Beautiful beautiful popsicles!!! And what a classic combination :)

  5. I have never thought to use pudding! Love everything about this, Beth!

  6. Genius. I love everything about this! Will be trying soon :)

  7. These look gorgeous and absolutely delicious. Great idea! Love it.

  8. These look so yummy! Perfect for summer. I would love to have you share these at the On Display Thursday Linky Party, going on now. http://eatitandsayyum.com/on-display-thursday-1/

  9. Not only do these look cute, but I bet they are delicious!! Can’t wait to try them. I would love it if you linked this up to my Motivate Me Monday linky party on IT’S A ginger SNAP.

  10. Oh my yum! Thank you so much for linking up to Monday Funday!

  11. I saw these on instagram, and I was so excited! These look awesome, Beth!

  12. Ohhhh these look so good! Love how you used the banana split flavors in these, what a great idea!!!! Wish I had one on a hot day like today!!!

  13. What I love most about these is how original they are! Coolest idea ever – and I love the hidden cherries!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.